Why did Prophet Muhammed need to appoint a successor or Imam in the first place?
The underlying assumption of this question is that the Qur'an as it exists today, in the form of a physical text or book, is sufficient for the guidance of mankind in all matters. However, Muhammad did not present, produce, or leave a book or a text. The Qur’an was purely oral and it was not a volume text – rather, every Qur’anic recitation or set of recitations was revealed through Muhammad to address very specific situations and events, and when events and new situations arose, the Prophet recited new recitations to respond and guide the community for that new situation and it continued this way until he died.
If this point is grasped and when it is realized that the Qur’an in its original context and form was nothing like a book or a scripture intended to provide guidance indefinitely into the future (if it were intended as such, the Prophet would have compiled it into a book or God would have sent it as a complete book), then the question of a Successor to Muhammad becomes an imperative.
Muhammad needs a successor for the following reasons:
- Practical necessity: all power and authority was held by Muhammad during his mission - religious, moral, military, economic, social, etc. Muhammad per the various Medinah verses of the Qur’an was the undisputed deputy of God’s will, the judge of all matters on God’s behalf, the conduit of Divine Guidance, and the intercessory mediator between God and humankind in matters of forgiveness and repentance and purification. It is obvious that Muhammad NOT appointing a successor would lead to chaos and a massive power struggle by various parties. Old tribal rivalries, feuds, politicking, and power grabs that existed prior to Muhammad uniting all these tribes would come back instantly. This point is cannot be refuted.
- Quranic Norms and Precedent: Several academic scholars of early Islam have analyzed the Qur’an as a historical and theological document and have concluded that the Qur’anic model of Prophetic succession is one where God always appoints heirs and successors to a Prophet from the family members and descendants of that Prophet and these descendants of Prophets are granted both Prophethood, the Kitab (a symbol for continuous Divine Guidance) and Hukm (theoretical and practical wisdom to judge) - - see 4:54, 57:26, 29:27, 6:84–89. When prior Prophets have successors (who are not always new prophets), then Prophet Muhammad should also have a successor. For example, here are specific cases mentioned in the Qur’an and the Bible contains more examples:
- The Qur’an in 3:33–34 emphasizes and declares a direct succession of Adam, Noah, Abraham, and Imran as a lineage of direcft descendants of God’s Chosen family.
- Thus, Abraham became a Prophet and Imam (2:124) as a direct descendant of Noah, who himself was a direct descendant of Adam (3:33–34 and Genesis).
- Abraham was succeeded by Ishmael and Ishmael’s direct descendants, whom the Qur’an calls “a nation submissive to God” (2:127–129, 14:35–40); Ishmael’s direct desendants include Prophet Muhammad.
- Abraham is also succeeded by Isaac, and Isaac by his son Jacob (21:72–73); the Prophets of Israel all descend from Jacob.
- Moses is deputized and succeeded by his brother Aaron (20:30, 25:35, 7:142, 20:32);
- Solomon inherits the authority of David (27:15–16).
- Zakariyyah prays for God to give him John to be both his heir and the heir (warith) to the House of Jacob (19:4–6).
- Prophetic family succession is an established principle in the Quran and according to S. M. Jafri, the number of verses emphasizing the special status of a Prophet’s family numbers to over 100. Based on the Quranic model, it is not only reasonable but obvious that Prophet Muhammad’s family, his Ahl al-Bayt, holds a special and sanctified status among all the believers – and this is also consistent with the Arabian concept of Ahl al-Bayt. Thus, it would be entirely natural if not axiomatic that Prophet Muhammad appointed his successor by Divine inspiration from among his Ahl al-Bayt just as prior Prophets did like Abraham, Ishmael, Isaac, Jacob, David, and Zakariyyah had done per the Qur’an.
- Divine Justice and Logical Necessity: Prophet Muhammad’s role was NOT to simply deliver a text-book called the Qur’an to his people and then leave them to it. This book-only model of divine guidance is NOT Qur’anic. In fact, in several places the Qur’an explicitly REJECTS the “book delivery” of Divine Guidance as something false – see 6:7, 4:153. Instead, the Qur’anic model of Divine Guidance is one where the Prophet BOTH recites divinely-inspired recitations (qur’ans) on a piecemeal and responsive basis AND ALSO provides continuous guidane to the community on all matters as and when they come up - see the verses 2:151, 62:2, 3:164, 16:44.
Explication of the divine intention of the revelation was among the functions that the Qur’an assigned to the Prophet. The Prophet functioned as the projection of the divine message embodied in the Qur’an. He was the living commentary of the Qur’an, inextricably related to the revelatory text. Without the Prophet the Qur’an was incomprehensible, just as without the Qur’an the Prophet was no prophet at all
– Abdul Aziz Sachedina, (“Scriptural Reasoning in Islam”, Journal of Scriptural Reasoning, 5/1 2005)
Basically, the Prophet played an indisputable and invaluable set of additional religious and spiritual functions in addition to reciting the Qur’an and the logic of Divine Justice necessitates that someone similar to the Prophet remains in the world after him to continue performing all the spiritual functions (listed below) which were essential to the early community and must continue to be fulfilled for all times:
- The Prophet Muḥammad is inspired by the Holy Spirit (42:52, 26:192-194)
- The Prophet Muḥammad is a mercy (raḥmah) to the worlds (21:107)
- The Prophet Muḥammad is merciful (raḥīm) to the Believers (9:128)
- The Prophet Muḥammad is kind (ra’ūf) to the Believers (9:128)
- The Prophet Muḥammad is light (nūr)from God (5:15) and a radiant lamp (sirāj munīr) (33:46)
- The Prophet Muḥammad is the teacher (mu‘allim) of the Book and Wisdom and new knowledge (62:2; 3:164; 2:151)
- The Prophet is the witness (shahīd) of humankind on the Day of Judgment (2:143, 33:46; 4:41)
- The Prophet Muḥammad is theguardian (walī) of the Believers (5:55)
- The Prophet Muḥammad prays to God for the Believer’s forgiveness (4:64, 63:5, 3:159, 60:12, 24:62)
- The Prophet Muḥammad forgives the Believers (5:13; 3:159; 7:199)
- The Prophet Muḥammad guides the Believers to the Straight Path (45:25)
- The Prophet Muḥammad’s nature or character is sublime (‘aẓīm) (68:4)
- The Prophet Muḥammad is the judge of the believers (4:65; 4:105; 24:51; 33:36)
- The Prophet Muḥammad makes things clear to the Believers (5:15; 5:19; 16:44; 16:64; 14:4)
- The Prophet Muḥammad purifies and sanctifies the believers (9:103)
- The Prophet Muḥammad holds authority (awlā) over the Believers (33:6)
- The Prophet Muḥammad summons the Believers to that which gives them life (8:24).
- The Prophet Muḥammad recites the Signs of God (2:151).
- The Prophet Muḥammad sends ṣalawāt (blessings, prayers) upon the Believers (9:103)
- The Prophet Muḥammad receives offerings (ṣadaqa) from the Believers (9:103; 58:12)
- The Prophet Muḥammad brings the people from darkness to Light (14:1; 14:5 65:11)
- The Prophet Muḥammad is a beautiful pattern for the Believers (33:21)
- The Prophet Muḥammad is the object of great respect and veneration (48:9, 49:1-3)
- The Prophet Muḥammad commands the lawful and forbids the wrong (7:157)
- He who gives their allegiance (bay‘ah) to the Prophet Muḥammad has given it to God (48:10)
- He who obeys the Prophet Muḥammad, obeys God (4:80; 4:64)